Wednesday, April 22, 2009

The Power of Power


As we discussed in class, the element of Power in the novel Power, is essential to the core of the story. The story explores power in its many forms and assesses its hold over a community and individuals. But what I found so fascinating about this novel was the types of power, or rather the things that were powerful, present in the book. Coming from a culture/community/society thta greatly differs from the Taiga tribe, it is interesting to learn what other people view as powerful. For example, the power of the Oni, or the wind, is very abstract. That an intangible element could provide a source if greatly respect, is fascinating to see. As is written in the book the wind is referred to as, "the spirit, the breath" (4). The concept of a powerful source such as wind to me gives a sense of awe, because wind is everywhere, as we discussed. I really found this to be an interesting topic to touch on because there is nothing like it in my own experiences. Similarly, the idea of the panther as an idylic being reminds me of nothing in my own personal experiences. I have often been surrounded by people who put faith and respect in inanimate objects, and in the book there is much power placed in living things. It is ineteresting to see the contrast between the two forms of respect that are paid to symbolic beings/objects.

This leads to the interesting dichotomy of two different forms of power that meet in the novel. As we discussed in class, American beliefs and tactics contrasted with that of the Taiga. It had not often occured to me that other cultures within the United States, that culturally abide by different laws, legally have to abide by the United States legal system. Obviously this would cause a distinct clash among cultrues. Dealing with this is clearly a difficult and controversial topic. After our discussion in class I was truly perplexed by the complicated situation proposed by the contrasting dynamics present in the two cultures. I began to sympathize with the many positions of the characters in the novel, especially that of Omishto trying to find her way.

The case of Ama and her 'crime' is not unique or unusual. In the United states there are many cases like this; cases in which cultural beliefs clash with American government laws and standards. Below is a link to an article concerning a 2008 case in which a young Native American boy was disciplined for violating dress code by having long hair at school. But his long hair is due to religious beliefs and it would offend said beliefs to cut his hair. Although this case certainly differs from the one presented by Ama in many ways, i thought it may provide a good example of how such culture/legal clashes do exist.





Thursday, April 2, 2009

Lucy

. These are all different covers of LUCY, I thought it might be interesting to compare, although I myself am unsure what to make of it :)




Lucy's relationship with Peggy seems to be one of usefulness on both parts. The two share a common element of loneliness and the desire to change that common trait. I believe Lucy is trying to full her empty void through her friendship with Peggy. This is most strongly suported by the fact that the two girls seem to be worlds apart and yet they find themselves desiring one anothers company. This is most likely becuase they are comfortable enough in each others presence to allow the other person to fill the empty void despite their lack of connectedness. For example, Lucy provides a description of this new found freidnship, "The funny thing was that Peggy and I were not alike, either, but that is just what we liked about each other; what we didnt have in common were things we approved of anyway." (61) It almost seems as if the fact that the two women have nothing in common is essential to the nature of their relationship; they fill in the voids with their differences. Had they been the same, how could they have filled anything for each other? They would have been in the exact same position they had begun in.


I find this relationship to be interesting because I feel as if the two women are unaccustomed to female relationships. Although Lucy has a certain relationship with Mariah and as readers we are unsure of Peggys past relationships, I still feel Kincaid has somehow managed to illustrate the two women in lacking in female relations, or at least not very good at them. Other than Mariah, the only female relationship Lucy is familiar with is one with that of her mother, and this relationship is not a particularly strong one. I believe this unaccustomed nature of Lucy and Peggy plays a strong role in their friendship. It may just be this quality as well as being lonely that are the only two common traits these two women share. Maybe they are comfortable with each other because they are not normally comfortable with other female relations, and they see this reflected in each other.